The 2024 Toronto Blue Jays season can be described in one word: disastrous.
What was expected to be another competitive season after back-to-back playoff appearances, the season ended with major disappointment, leaving both fans and players frustrated and questioning the direction of the organization. As the season officially comes to a close this week, it’s clear that major changes need to be made if the Blue Jays hope to compete in the coming years.
The most glaring indication of the Blue Jays’ failure this year is easy to notice on paper: their record, finishing 74-88, 14 games below .500. Following consecutive seasons of 89, 92, and 91 wins , this was a significant regression. Last year, the team finished with another playoff birth, and the expectations for 2024 still remained high, with many predicting at least another playoff push. Unfortunately, the opposite occurred. Mismanagement on multiple levels led to underperformance, and the Jays ultimately failed to live up to their potential.
One of the season’s biggest disappointments was the mismanagement across the board. From questionable decisions made by the manager John Schneider, to the general manager Ross Atkins’ failure to address key roster issues, the organization seemed to lack a clear strategy. Whether it was the poor pitching rotation at times, ineffective bullpen management, or the inability to adapt to injuries, the Blue Jays seemed one step behind all season.
Offensively, Bo Bichette and George Springer were poor, with batting averages respectfully of .225, and .220, significantly lower then both of their career averages. Key contributions from previous seasons like Davis Schneider, and Alejandro Kirk, failed to deliver in crucial moments. On the mound, the pitching staff struggled mightily, with an team ERA of 4.29. For context, last year they had a 2.81 ERA, good enough for second best in baseball. These struggles are signs of larger issues within the organization that must be addressed.
Despite the overwhelming negative season, there were still a few bright spots this season. The emergence of Bowden Francis with his great season on the mound, provides some hope for a future ace. It was great to see Vladimir Guerrero Jr. return to form this season, getting back to his all star ways. These two young stars delivered strong performances all season, providing hope within the team.
Another positive takeaway from the season was the resilience of the fan base. Despite the losses, fans stuck with the Jays, filling the stands showing their support, reflecting the passion and hope that remains for baseball in Toronto.
So, what needs to change?
As the team moves into the offseason, it’s clear changes are needed. The front office must be held accountable for their mistakes, and there should be a clear vision to address the team’s weaknesses. A new coach (or, at the very least) a new managerial approach could breathe fresh life into the team, as the Jays haven’t won a playoff game since 2016. Key additions to the bullpen and offence aren’t a want…they’re a NEED if Toronto wishes to be competitive again.
There are reasons to be optimistic, however.
With a young talent pool, including players acquired via selling at the deadline like Will Wagner and Joey Loperfido, and the right changes in leadership, the Blue Jays can turn things around. It’s up to the organization to make the necessary adjustments however, and not be all talk.
This season will go down as a disappointing one for the Toronto Blue Jays. Yet, with the right changes and fresh look, there is hope Toronto can bounce back. We’ll watch closely this offseason, hoping the organization finally gets it right.